To Harness or Not To Harness? That is the Question
… that was addressed by a recent study that is the topic of this month’s newsletter. You’ve probably noticed an upsurge during the last several years in the use of harnesses as an alternative to collars. At the same time, there has been a concern that harnesses might affect dogs’ gait. Researchers in the UK investigated exactly that question by comparing the effect of restrictive and non-restrictive harnesses on shoulder extension in dogs when walking and trotting.
There are two main categories of harnesses: those that are considered non-restrictive to front limb movement, which have a Y-shaped chest strap and those considered restrictive, which have a strap that lies across the chest horizontally.
In this study, 9 dogs were moved at a walk and a trot on a treadmill wearing either no harness, a non-restrictive harness (an X-back mushing harness; Trixie Fusion harness), or a restrictive harness (Easy Walk harness). The researchers placed markers on the sides of the dogs’ legs and used video cameras to measure the angle of the shoulder when the front limb was in maximal extension (when the leg was placed furthest forward).
Results of the Study: No harness vs. non-restrictive harness vs. restrictive harness
- Dogs wearing only a collar had significantly more shoulder extension, both while walking and trotting, than dogs wearing either type of harness.
- Dogs wearing non-restrictive harnesses had significantly less shoulder extension than dogs wearing restrictive harnesses when both walking and trotting. That was the unexpected finding, and we’ll look at those results more closely in a minute.
The researchers also examined the effect of weights added to the harness to try to simulate the dog pulling against the harness. The weights were used in a way that caused the harness to be pulled up and away from the dog’s back at an approximately 45o angle, similar to how the harness would be pulled on if a person were walking behind the dog.
Results of the Study: Weights vs. No Weights
- Dogs walking using non-restrictive harnesses with weights had significantly less shoulder extension than dogs wearing non-restrictive harnesses without weights or than those wearing restrictive harnesses with or without weights.
- Dogs trotting using non-restrictive harnesses with weights had significantly less shoulder extension than dogs wearing restrictive harnesses with or without weights.
One limitation of the study mentioned by the authors was that their system was not designed to measure step or stride length or stance time, which can affect shoulder extension. However, a previous harness study did look at those parameters. That study showed that both non-restrictive and restrictive harnesses alter step and stride length as compared to the same dogs wearing just a collar.
|1. Why would the so-called non-restrictive harness reduce shoulder extension more than the restrictive harness?|
A: In my opinion, it might be a function of harness fit. The straps that lie in front of the scapula (shoulder blade) are pressing into the dog’s body , almost certainly preventing the dog from moving its scapula forward. This, of course, would limit shoulder extension.
A non-restrictive harness needs to be fitted so that it is tight around the dog’s neck. That way, when the dog is pulling, the Y-shaped chest strap applies pressure to the manubrium (the front of the sternum), and the straps on the side of the neck should not slide back to lie against the shoulder blade. For most dogs, this means that the neck part of the harness needs to be adjustable and needs to have a clip, so that it doesn’t have to be large enough to slip over the dog’s head.
2. Why would the addition of weights to the non-restrictive harness further reduce the dog’s shoulder extension?
A: See answer to question 1. I think that when the weights pulled on the harness, those loose side straps pulled even harder against the dog’s shoulder blades, further restricting shoulder extension.
|3. Why would the addition of weights to the restrictive harness allow the dog to have more shoulder extension?|
A: It is likely that the weights pulling upwards and backwards on the restrictive harness allowed the horizontal band to rise up on the dog’s front, taking some of the pressure of that band off of the shoulder joint . This would allow the dog to extend its shoulder further (although it might put more pressure on the dog’s neck).
- Because two studies now provide good evidence that both restrictive and non-restrictive harnesses alter dogs’ gaits, a collar might be a better choice for many dogs. However, dogs wearing collars should be trained to walk politely, without pulling, on a leash.
1. Lafuente MP, Provis L, Schmalz EA. Effects of restrictive and non-restrictive harnesses on shoulder extension in dogs at walk and trot. Vet Record 2018;1-7. doi: 10.1136/vr.104946 Read the PDF
2. Carr BJ, Dresse K, Zink MC. The effects of five commercially available harnesses on
canine gait. Proceedings of ACVS Surgical Summit, 2016. Read the PDF
3. Rugaas T. My Dog Pulls. What Do I Do? 2005. Dogwise Publishing.